AskTuscany

Where is the best base for a week in Tuscany?

places|2026-11-16

Quick answer: there is no single best base, because Tuscany is too big to see from one place. Without a car, base yourself in Florence or Siena. With a car, split the week between two bases: one in Chianti or near Siena, and one in the Val d'Orcia.

First question: car or no car?

Without a car you need a town with good public transport.

  • Florence has the best train connections: Pisa, Lucca, Arezzo, Bologna and Siena are each about an hour away.
  • Siena has better buses to the hill towns, including San Gimignano and Montepulciano, and is far quieter in the evening.
  • Lucca works for the north-west: Pisa, the coast and the Garfagnana hills.

With a car almost anywhere works, and a town or farm in the countryside becomes the better choice.

The main bases compared

| Base | Reach in under an hour | Best for | Keep in mind | |---|---|---|---| | Florence | Fiesole, Chianti's northern edge, Prato | Art, first visits, no car | A poor base for driving: traffic, restricted zone, parking | | Siena | San Gimignano, Monteriggioni, Chianti, the Crete Senesi | A beautiful city with evenings to match | Awkward with a car: parking is outside the walls | | Chianti (Greve, Panzano, Radda, Castellina) | Florence, Siena, San Gimignano | Wine, scenery, farm stays, a central position | Slow, winding roads; you drive everywhere | | Val d'Orcia (Pienza, San Quirico, Montepulciano, Montalcino) | Each other, Bagno Vignoni, Cortona, Lake Trasimeno | The postcard landscape, wine, hot springs | Too far south for day trips to Florence, Pisa or Lucca | | Lucca | Pisa, Viareggio, the Garfagnana | A flat, liveable town; good by train | Far from Siena and the south | | Maremma or the coast | Beaches, Etruscan sites, Pitigliano | Summer, families, a second visit | A different trip from the hill-town circuit |

One base or two?

For a week, two. Tuscany's highlights fall into three clusters: Florence and the north, Siena and Chianti in the middle, and the Val d'Orcia in the south. From any single base, one of the three is a two-hour drive each way.

A split that works: three or four nights in Chianti or near Siena, then three in the Val d'Orcia. You change hotel only once and never drive more than an hour.

Town or farm stay?

  • A small town lets you walk to dinner and have a glass of wine without thinking about the drive home. Pienza, Montepulciano, San Quirico, Radda and Castellina are good examples.
  • An agriturismo gives you a pool, space and silence, but every meal out means driving on unlit country roads. Choose one within ten minutes of a town, or one that serves dinner.

What to check before booking

  • Parking. Hill towns keep visitors' cars outside the walls. Ask where you leave it and how far you carry your bags.
  • Restaurants within walking distance, and whether they open all week in low season.
  • The road. A "panoramic position" at the end of three kilometres of gravel track is lovely until you have driven it for the sixth time in the dark.

Real experiences: the good, the fair and the bad

A couple who rented an apartment in Siena for a week, having also tried a farm in the country, found the time in Siena better spent: "One of our best trips ever." šŸ”— Rick Steves forum

A long-standing member's answer to "Montepulciano or Chianti?": most people on that forum pick Montepulciano because the guidebook does, but the right base depends entirely on which towns you want to visit. šŸ”— Rick Steves forum

The opposite verdict on Siena, from a driver: "I would definitely not make Siena my home base with a car." Parking is frustrating and traffic can be heavy. šŸ”— Rick Steves forum

Related questions

Last verified: November 2026.

Related Questions

Didn't find what you're looking for?

Ask your question